Thoughts on Criticism

There are two moments of criticism I remember very clearly:

  1. The first time I released an app on the App Store
  2. The first time I tried public speaking

I publicly released my first mobile app on June 24th, 2012. It was an exciting moment for me! I received my first customer feedback the very next day. I was excited to open his email (or so I thought)…

“Your app SUCKS. I want my dollar back”
Sent from my iPhone

Ouch. That hurt. So many negative emotions went through my mind:

  • The Chrome version of this app has thousands of weekly users; the app can’t be too bad (Pride).
  • This customer has no idea how long I worked on this app (Anger).
  • The app is admittedly simple but what more does he expect (Frustration).
  • Maybe he is right. Maybe it does suck. (Self-doubt).
  • What if he leaves a one-star review? Maybe I should remove the app from the store (Embarrassment).

My first experience with public speaking was not much different. There was a quarterly meeting between ODOT Central Office and District staff. It was a relatively small audience — around 30 people. But still, my first opportunity to try and professional speak in front of a crowd! I tried to compare work zone plan reviews to pregnancy. (I cringe writing this but my wife was pregnant at the time so cut me a little slack). Big shocker, the initial feedback was rough. My boss cut me off and finished the presentation. I felt super embarrassed. The initial feelings were all negative. Shame. Anger. Self-pity. You name it.

In both of these situations I felt a strong urge to give up.

  • To remove the app from the App Store and quit making apps.
  • To never try public speaking again.

These felt like reasonable reactions at the time.

But, after cooling down a bit, I realized I had another option: to try and understand the criticism as feedback. Even though it hurt — at least I was getting feedback. So, I let my emotions cool and asked for more specifics.

Regarding the angry email from the guy who hated my app: I ended up responding with a nice email. I explained my limited experience in creating and marketing apps and I asked a few questions about his expectations. He was generous enough to engage in a more fruitful conversation with plenty of good feedback. I took a lot of his suggestions and built them into future app updates. The app eventually became my most successful App Store product for years — generating tens of thousands of dollars in sales.

Quick aside:

I finally had to stop supporting this app a couple of months ago. Before completely shutting it down I helped a few loyal customers transition to other solutions. The last customer feedback I received for the app was more encouraging than my first customer email:

“Thank you so much! I appreciate the help! Definitely gonna miss your app! It was amazing!”

A similar story unfolded with public speaking. I privately asked for feedback on how I could improve. I started to learn about better preparing for presentations and knowing my audience. And, thankfully, I was given more opportunities to try again. Over time I was asked to speak at more and more conferences and fine-tuned my speaking abilities. A handful of years later I was asked to give a presentation as a fill-in for the ODOT Director to other executive-level staff. And this presentation ended with an engaged audience asking relevant questions, not me getting cut off for poor performance.

Neither improvement would have taken place if I let the initial criticism cripple me. Within each criticism was a nugget of truth. Small lessons to be learned. Compared to future versions of my apps, the first version did fall short. And, my initial public speaking attempts were awkward. Had I let the natural instinct to resist criticism take over, I may never have uncovered these growth opportunities.

Yes, criticism can sting! But, if you allow it, criticism can also improve your craft.

About The Author

John MacAdam is a Professional Transportation Engineer and IT Consultant from Columbus, Ohio. He runs his own business helping companies deliver and understand technology.

He is currently writing about living with less and running a side business. Follow him on LinkedIn for monthly articles.

Originally published at



Professional Transportation Engineer and IT Consultant from Columbus, Ohio. Helping companies deliver and understand technology.

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
John MacAdam

Professional Transportation Engineer and IT Consultant from Columbus, Ohio. Helping companies deliver and understand technology.